Educational inequality in Russian schools: the influence of territorial factor

Educational inequality is constantly in the scope of foreign and Russian scientists alike, however there are differences in the way it is interpreted. If we were to consider education as a system, we could acknowledge the existence of inequality in initial educational opportunities (at the system’s gateway), as well as inequality in the education process itself (within the system), and inequality of education results (when transitioning from one stage to the next, or when exiting the system). The goal of this study was to determine the specifics of how territorial factor in a specific type of environment influences educational inequality among children. Part of the study was to verify the suggestion that this factor has been increasing its influence in Russia. Empirical data was collected using focus group and expert interview methods. Adult and adolescent participants of the study were asked questions about the interpretation of educational inequality (how it manifests in schooling), determining factors which affect the reproduction of educational inequality, including whether there is a territorial aspect to how it manifests. Study participants described local features in educational inequality, comparing city and village, large and small towns. The logic of comparing large and small settlements can be traced throughout the remarks of informants of all ages. Children spoke more of inequality within the education system, citing examples such as differences in how schools are equipped, varying level of skill among teachers, differences in the amount of cultural-leisure, educational and other facilities in their settlement. Experts also pointed out examples of educational inequality at the system’s “gateways” and “exits”, while speaking about socio-cultural and financial capital being possible sources for educational inequality, which from an organizational standpoint is considered by the study participants on the level of school – locale – region. The suggestion that territorial factor currently plays an increased role in reproducing educational inequality needs to be further researched utilizing regional statistical data.

region, educational inequality, school, educational opportunities, family

Accessibility of higher education in the regions of Russia. Ed. by A.D. Gromov, D.P. Platonova, D.S. Semionov, T.L. Pyrova. Moscow, NRU HSE publ., 2016: 32 (In Russ.).

Amini C., Nivorozhkin E. The urban–rural divide in educational outcomes: Evidence from Russia. International Journal of Educational Development, 2015; 44: 118–133. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijedudev.2015.07.006

Assessment of the quality of secondary education: an analysis of the dynamics over 15 years. Ed. by. D. L. Konstantinovskiy, F. E. Sheregi, M. N. Mihaleva. Moscow: Centr social'nogo prognozirovanija i marketinga, 2018: 36 (In Russ.).

Carnoy M., Khavenson T., Ivanova A. Using TIMSS and PISA results to inform educational policy: a study of Russia and its neighbours. Compare: A Journal of Comparative and International Education, 2015; vol. 45, 2: 248–271. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/03057925.2013.855002

Filipova A. G. The Social Protection of Childhood in Modern Russia. Saint-Petersburg: Asterion, 2012: 247 (In Russ.).

Filipova A. G., Vysotskaya A. V. Studying General Secondary Education Systems in the Regions of Russia: the «Gray Box'». Method. Regionologiya = Regionology, 2018; 26; 1 (102): 155–178. DOI: 10.15507/2413-1407.102.026.201801.155-178 (In Russ.).

Filipova A. G., Vysotskaya A. V. The Method of building a simulation model (on example of average use in the Russian regions). Vestnik Instituta sotziologii = Bulletin of Institute of Sociology, 2017; 23: 71–89. DOI: https://doi.org/10.19181/vis.2017.23.4.481 (In Russ.).

Fini R. School Achievement in Italy An Empirical View. International Studies in Educational Inequality, 2007; vol. 2: 157–175.

Gorshkov M.K., Sheregi F.E. National project "Education": expert estimates and the position of the population. Moscow, 2018: 464 (In Russ.).

Havenson T. E., Kersha Y. D. Comparative analysis of the results of the PISA and TIMSS tests in Russia and European countries. Moscow: NRU HSE publ., 2017: 32 (In Russ.).

Kapuza A.V., Kersha Y.D., Zakharov A.B., Khavenson T.E. Educational Attainment and Social Inequality in Russia: Dynamics and Correlations with Education Policies. Voprosy obrazovaniya = Educational Studies, 2017; 4: 10–35 (In Russ.).

Konstantinovskiy D. L. Dynamics of inequality: Russian youth in a changing society: Orientations and ways in education (from the 1960th to the 2000th). Moscow: Editorial URSS, 1999: 344 (In Russ.).

Konstantinovskiy D. L. Inequality and education. Experience of sociological researches of vital start of the Russian youth (1960th – beginning of 2000). Moscow: CSP, 2008: 552 (In Russ.).

Konstantinovskiy D. L. Inequality in education: situation in Russia. Monitoring obshchestvennogo mneniya: economicheskie i social'nye peremeny = Public opinion monitoring: economic and social change, 2010; 5 (99): 40–65 (In Russ.).

Konstantinovskiy D. L., Vakhshtayn V. S., Kurakin D. Y., Mikhaylova Y. M. Accessibility of quality general education in Russia: opportunities and limitations. Voprosy obrazovaniya = Educational Studies, 2006; 2: 186–201 (In Russ.).

Kosyakova J. A., Yastrebov G. A., Yanbarisova D. M., Kurakin D. Y. The Reproduction of Social Inequality in the Russian Educational System. Zhurnal sociologii i social'noy antropologii = Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology, 2016; vol. 19, 5: 76–97 (In Russ.).

Kulich N., Skopek Y., Triventi M., Demrikh Y., Blosfeld Kh.-P. High Expectations? Lessons Learned from a Cross-National and Multidisciplinary Study on the Role of Childcare and Early Education in Social Inequality. Zhurnal sociologii I social'noy antropologii = Journal of Sociology and Social Anthropology, 2016; 19; 5 (88): 15–38 (In Russ.).

Larina G. S., Markina V. M. Teachers’ beliefs about student diversity: exclusive and inclusive models. Basic research program. Working papers series: education. WP BRP 43. EDU, 2017: 28.

Lipay T. P. The manifestation of stigma in education. Sociologicheskie issledovaniya = Sociological Studies, 2004; 10: 140–141 (In Russ.).

Petrenko E. S., Galitskaya E. G., Petrenko K. V. Family Resources and the Educational Trajectories of Children and Adults. Voprosy obrazovaniya = Educational Studies, 2007; 3: 240–257 (In Russ.).

Prakhov I. A. Barriers Limiting Access to Quality Higher Education in the Context of the USE: Family and School as Constraining Factors. Voprosy obrazovaniya = Educational Studies, 2015; 1: 88–117 (In Russ.).

Sobkin V. S. Ethnos. Identity. Education. Works on sociology of education. Volume IV. Issue VI. Moscow: ISE of RAE, 1998: 268 (In Russ.).

Sobkin V. S. Sociologiya obrazovaniya. Sociology of education. Works on sociology of education: collection of articles. Moscow: ISE of RAE, 2009: 56 (In Russ.).

Sobkin V. S. The writings on the sociology of education: monograph. Moscow: ISE of RAE, 2009: 292 (In Russ.).

Sobkin V. S. Works on sociology of education: conversations, technologies, methods. Moscow: ISE of RAE, 2005: 222 (In Russ.).

Vysotskaya A.V. The system of secondary general education in the Russian regions: the construction of a simulation model. Oykumena. Regionovedcheskie issledovaniya = Oikumena. Regionalistic Studies, 2018; 1 (44): 30–38. DOI: 10.24866/1998-6785/2018-1/30-37 (In Russ.).

Yudin B. G., Rutkevich M. N. and oth. Human potential of Russia: intellectual, social, cultural dimensions: monograph. Moscow, IH of RAS, 2002: 265 (In Russ.).