Problematization of the development of non-capital cities in the works of Soviet and post-Soviet researchers

The article is dedicated to a critical analysis of the theoretical and methodological developments of Soviet and Russian scientists in the field of urbanism and sociology of the city. The relevance of this work is seen in the fact that today the desire of a significant part of Russian citizens (especially young people) to move to Moscow, St. Petersburg and a number of large cities - centres of the subjects of the Russian Federation leads to a weakening of the spatial framework of the country. This makes it important to study the topic in the context of urbanisation processes in general. The purpose of the article is to reveal the features of the approaches of domestic scientists to the problems of the city, and non-capital cities in particular, as well as their general dynamics in the late Soviet, post-Soviet and modern periods.

In the 1970s–1980s urbanisation processes in the USSR were subordinated to production (the leading theme was “city and labor”); the settlement strategy continued, the advantages and contradictions of new cities were noted, the importance of including small towns in the agglomeration was emphasised. The foundations of urban social planning were developed, the ideology of "developed socialism" contributed to the formation of the problematics of the urban way of life and communities.

During the Perestroika period, many of the principles of urban development were formulated in opposition to the Soviet ones. The city was understood as a self-developing system, the individual was declared the measure of urban processes. The settlement system, that determines the most acute problems of new cities, was critically assessed. Differentiation of the capital and non-capital cities of Russia, serious contradictions in the development of small towns, and the weakening of agglomerations were noted. The focus was made on maintaining the large and largest urban centres.

In the 2000s, extreme criticism of Soviet urbanisation was overcome, strategic urban planning, the idea of preserving the network of small and medium-sized cities, and the development of agglomerations as the basis for the country's spatial development were promoted. The direction of research of intercity and intracity stratification in the context of problems of spatial inequality, urban activism and urban social environment was being developed.

The authors come to the conclusion that Russia has accumulated a wealth of experience in studying urbanisation processes. This suggests that in the future it will be possible to successfully combine the use of cities as reference points for the country's integration with the planning ideas developed during the Soviet period and models for the formation of a comfortable urban space, based on the activities of local communities.

city, city sociology, non-capital cities, urbanisation, social planning, spatial development, urban communities

1. Altynbaev R. Z. Social'no-infrastrukturnyj kompleks kak faktor sovershenstvovanija obraza zhizni molodogo goroda (na primere g. Naberezhnye Chelny RT): avtoreferat dis. ... k. social. n. [Socio-infrastructural complex as a factor of improving the lifestyle of a young city (on the example of Naberezhnye Chelny, RT): abstract of the dissertation of the Candidate of Sociological Sciences]. Kazan', 1994: 16 (in Russ.).

2. Animica E. G., Sbrodova N. V., Ivleva I. V. Issledovanie jevoljucii goroda: ot zarozhdenija, prosperiti k depressii (na primere monoprofil'nogo goroda) [Study of Town Evolution: from the Formation, Prosperity to Depression (Case Study of a Company Town]. Izvestija Ural'skogo gosudarstvennogo jekonomicheskogo universiteta. 2011: 2: 41–46 (in Russ.).

3. Forum “Issledovaniia goroda” [Forum “Urban Studies”]. Antropologicheskii Forum. 2010: 12: 7–206. Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: https://anthropologie.kunstkamera.ru/files/pdf/012/12_forum.pdf (in Russ.).

4. Artjomova O. Ju. Social'naja antropologija v sovremennom provincial'nom gorode [Social anthropology in a modern provincial city]. Novye rossijskie gumanitarnye issledovanija. Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: http://nrgumis.ru/articles/360/ (in Russ.).

5. Akhiezer A. S. Dialektika urbanizacii i migracii v Rossii [Dialectics of urbanization and migration in Russia]. Obshhestvennye nauki i sovremennost', 2000: 1: 78−89 (in Russ.).

6. Akhiezer A. S., Kogan L. B., Janickij O. N. Urbanizacija, obshhestvo i nauchno-tehnicheskaja revoljucija [Urbanization, society, and the scientific and technological revolution]. Voprosy filosofii, 1969: 2: 43–53 (in Russ.).

7. Bakanov S. A. Malyj sovetskij gorod 1960−80-h gg. v zerkale otechestvennoj urbanistiki [Small Soviet city of the 1960s–80s in the mirror of Russian Urbanizm]. Novyj istoricheskij vestnik, 2003: 9: 123−133 (in Russ.).

8. Borshhevskij M. V., Uspenskij S. V., Shkaratan O. I. Gorod. Metodologicheskie problemy kompleksnogo social'nogo i jekonomicheskogo planirovanija [City. Methodological problems of complex social and economic planning]. Moscow, Nauka, 1975: 204 (in Russ.).

9. Breslavsky A. S. Post-Soviet Ulan-Ude: Cultural Space and Images of the City (1991–2011). Ulan-Ude, Buryat State University Publishing Department, 2012: 156 (in Russ.).

10. Vagin V. V. Russkij provincial'nyj gorod [Russian provincial town: main aspects of life]. Mir Rossii, 1997: 4: 53–88 (in Russ.).

11. Vivchar T. A. Strategija sozdanija konkurentnyh preimushhestv territorii: razvitie tvorcheskoj jekonomiki ili bor'ba za administrativnyj resurs? (na primere Leningradskoj oblasti) [Strategy of creation of competitive advantages of the territory: development of creative economy or fight for an administrative resource? (the case of Leningrad region)]. Creative industries in the city: challenges, projects and solutions. Collection of scientific articles of students and teachers of the Higher School of Economics / Ed. by Yu. O. Papushina, M. V. Matetskaya. St. Petersburg, Levsha, 2012: 121−133 (in Russ.).

12. Vizgalov D. V. Brending goroda [City Branding]. Moscow, Fond ekonomiki goroda, 2011: 160 (in Russ.).

13. Glazychev V. L. Glubinnaja Rossija: 2000-2002 [Deep Russia: 2000–2002]. Moscow, Novoe izdatel’stvo publ., 2005: 325 (in Russ.).

14. Glazychev V. L. Gorod bez granic [City without borders]. Moscow, Izdatel'skij dom «Territorija budushhego», 2011: 400 (in Russ.).

15. Glazychev V. L. Razvitie mestnogo samoupravlenija i stanovlenie grazhdanskogo obshhestva v Rossii [Development of local self-government and formation of civil society in Russia]. Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: http://www.glazychev.ru/habitations&cities/1997_razvitie_mestnogo_samoupravlenia.htm (in Russ.).

16. Glazychev V. L. Urbanisztika [Urban Studies]. Moscow, Evropa, 2008: 220 (in Russ.).

17. Gorod: problemy social'nogo razvitija [The city: problems of social development]. / Ed. by A. V. Dmitrieva, M. N. Mezhevicha. Leningrad, Nauka, 1982: 173 (in Russ.).

18. Gorodskie lokal'nye identichnosti kak osnova formirovanija ustojchivyh mestnyh soobshhestv. Issledovanie obshhegorodskih identichnostej zhitelej Vladimira, Smolenska, Jaroslavlja [Urban local identities as the basis for the formation of sustainable local communities. Researchof citywide identities of residents of Vladimir, Smolensk, Yaroslavl] / I. V. Zadorin, R. V. Evstifeev, P. L. Krupkin, S. D. Lebedev, L. V. Shubina. Moscow, 2016: 120. Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: http://www.zircon.ru/upload/iblock/a5a/Izbrannoe_ZIRCON_GLI_2015.pdf (in Russ.).

19. Gun’ko M. S., Eriomenko Y. A., Batunova E. Ju. Planning Strategies in the Context of Urban Shrinkage in Russia: Evidence from Small and Medium-sized Cities. Mir Rossii, 2020: 29 (3): 121–141 (in Russ.). DOI:  https://doi.org/10.17323/1811-038X-2020-29-3-121-141

20. Dmitriev A. V., Mezhevich M. N. SSSR – SShA: social'noe razvitie v gorodah (opyt sravnitel'nogo analiza) [USSR – USA: social development in cities (comparative analysis experience)]. Leningrad, Nauka, 1989: 168 (in Russ.).

21. Dridze T. M., Orlova E. A. Situacionnyj analiz obraza zhizni pri prognozirovanii i proektirovanii sociokul'turnyh processov [Situational analysis of lifestyle in forecasting and designing socio-cultural processes]. Pushhino, USSR Academy of Sciences publ., 1986: 53 (in Russ.).

22. Dridze T. M. Tehnologija prognoznogo social'nogo proektirovanija i social'noj kommunikacii v jekoantropocentricheskoj paradigme social'nogo poznanija. Programma speckursa [The technology of predictive social design and social communication in the ecoanthropocentric paradigm of social cognition. Syllabus]. Moscow; 2003. Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: http://ecsocman.hse.ru/data/504/673/1219/Dridze_TM.pdf (in Russ.).

23. Djatlov V. I., Grigorichev K. V. Jetnichnost' v gorodskom prostranstve: ot sovetskogo k postsovetskomu [Ethnicity in Urban Space: from Soviet to Post-Soviet Period]. Izvestija Irkutskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Serija Politologija. Religiovedenie, 2014: 10: 5−7 (in Russ.).

24. Zhelnina A. A. Creative activities for selected cider: social exclusion and the creative spaces of Saint Petersburg. Creative industries in the city: challenges, projects and solutions. Collection of scientific articles of students and teachers of the Higher School of Economics / Ed. by Yu. O. Papushina, M. V. Matetskaya. St. Petersburg, Levsha, 2012: 42−57 (in Russ.).

25. Zamjatina N. Ju., Piljasov A. N. New industrial policyin mono-profile cities of Russia. Sovremennye proizvoditel'nye sily, 2015: 1: 37−55 (in Russ.).

26. Zamjatina N. Ju., Piljasov A. N. Rossija, kotoruju my obreli: issleduja prostranstvo na mikrourovne [The Russia we Found: Exploring Space at the Micro level]. Moscow, Novij khronograf, 2013: 548 (in Russ.).

27. Zajonchkovskaja Zh. A. Novosely v gorodah. Metody izuchenija prizhivaemosti [New settlers in the cities. Methods of studying survival rate]. Moscow, Statistika, 1972: 164 (in Russ.).

28. Zimin V. P. Kadastrovaja ocenka zemel' monogorodov s uchetom pokazatelej gradoobrazujushhih predprijatij (na primere Murmanskoj oblasti): diss. …k. tehn. n. [Cadastral assessment of the land of single-industry towns, taking into account the indicators of the city-forming enterprises (on the example of the Murmansk region): diss. ... candidate of technical sciences]. St. Petersburg, 2018: 152 (in Russ.).

29. Zubarevich N. V., Safronov S. G. Russia largest cities development in 2010s. Regional'nye issledovanija, 2019: 1(63): 39–51 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.5922/1994-5280-2019-1-4

30. Karachurina L. B. Urbanization in Russian style: Trends of the last 20 years. Otechestvennye zapiski, 2012: 3: 10−24 (in Russ.).

31. Kogan L. B. Byt' gorozhaninom [Beeing a city dweller]. Moscow, Mysl', 1990: 205 (in Russ.).

32. Kogan L. B. Urbanizacija i nekotorye voprosy gorodskoj kul'tury [Urbanization and some issues of urban culture]. Urbanizacija, nauchno-tehnicheskaja revoljucija i rabochij klass. Moscow, Nauka, 1972: 98−111 (in Russ.).

33. Komarova T. M., Kalinina I. V., Solovchenkov S. A. Subjective and objective assessments of personalemployment at the Russian Far East (Jewish Autonomous Region as a case study). Vestnik instituta sotziologii, 2021: 12: 2: 101–122 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.19181/vis.2021.12.2.717

34. Constructing ethnicity: Ethnic Communities of St. Petersburg / Ed. by V. Voronkov, I. Osval'd. St. Petersburg, Dmitrij Bulanin, 1998: 300 (in Russ.).

35. Kordonsky S., Plusnin Ju. Archaic Economic Institutions: “Scattered Manufactories” in Russian Towns. Mir Rossii, 2018: 27: 4: 6–30 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.17323/1811-038X-2018-27-4-6-30

36. Krotov P. P., Buravoj M., Lytkina T. S. Zhilishhnaja stratifikacija goroda: rynochnaja jevoljucija sovetskoj modeli [Housing stratification of the city: the market evolution of the Soviet model]. Syktyvkar, VSEBS FRC Komi SC UB RAS publ., 2003: 99 (in Russ.).

37. Kucev G. F. Novye goroda (sociologicheskij ocherk na materialah Sibiri) [New cities (a sociological essay on the materials of Siberia)]. Moscow, Mysl', 1982: 272 (in Russ.).

38. Lavrinenko A. Tvorcheskie industrii kak drajver razvitija malyh gorodov [The creative industries as the driver of development of small cities]. Social'naja jekonomika lokal'nogo: Sbornik nauchnyh statej / Ed. by O. V. Karpova, N. E. Prjanishnikova. Moscow, 2016: 95−101 (in Russ.).

39. Lappo G. M. Goroda na puti v budushhee [Cities on the road to the future]. Moscow, Mysl', 1987: 236 (in Russ.).

40. Leksin V. N. Goroda vlasti: administrativnye centry Rossii [Cities of Power: Administrative Centres of Russia]. Mir Rossii, 2009: 18(1): 3–33 (in Russ.).

41. Malye goroda v social'nom prostranstve Rossii [Small towns in the social space of the Russian Federation] / Ed. by V. V. Markin, M. F. Chernysh; Foreword: M. K. Gorshkov. Moscow, FCTAS RAS publ., 2019: 545. Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: https://www.isras.ru/index.php?page_id=1198&id=7751 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.19181/monogr.978-5-89697-323-2.2019

42. Malyj gorod. Social'no-demograficheskoe issledovanie nebol'shogo goroda [Small town. Socio-demographic study of a small town] / Ed. by B. S. Horev. Moscow, Moscow State University publ., 1972: 248 (in Russ.).

43. Manaeva I. V. Cities and towns of Russia: Classification and typology. Regional Economics: Theory and Practice, 2018: 16: 7: 1235–1249 (in Russ.). DOI: https://doi.org/10.24891/re.16.7.1235

44. Markov E. M. Razvitie malyh i srednih gorodov [Development of small and medium-sized cities]. Moscow, Znanie, 1983: 64 (in Russ.).

45. Medvedeva L. N. Average cities at the Russian modernization space Jekonomicheskoe vozrozhdenie Rossii, 2011: 3: 150–154 (in Russ.).

46. Meerovich M. G. Soviet Monoprofile Cities: the Story Behind and Key Features. Vestnik Kemerovskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta, 2018: 1: 53–64 (in Russ.). DOI: https://doi.org/10.21603/2078-8975-2018-1-53-65

47. Meerovich M. G. Uniqueness of Urbanization in the USSR. Vestnik of Tomsk state university of architecture and building, 2015: 2: 9–16 (in Russ.). DOI: https://doi.org/10.7480/projectbaikal.45.905

48. Varshaver E., Rocheva A., Ivanov N., Jermakova M. Residential Concentrations of Migrants in Russian Cities: Is There a Pattern? Sotsiologicheskoe obozrenie, 2020: 19: 2: 225–253 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.17323/1728-192x-2020-2-225-253

49. Metodologija social'no-jekonomicheskogo planirovanija goroda [Methodology of socio-economic planning of the city] / Ed. by V. A. Vorotilov, G. N. Cherkasov. Leningrad, Nauka, 1980: 184 (in Russ.).

50. Mkrtchyan N. V., Florinskaya Y. F. Residents of Small and Mid-Size Towns of Russia: Labor Migration as an Alternative to Permanent Transfer. The Journal of the New Economic Association, 2019: 3 (in Russ.). DOI: https://doi.org/10.31737/2221-2264-2019-43-3-4

51. Monogorod: upravlenie razvitiem [Single-industry town: management of development] / Ed. by T. V. Uskova. Vologda, VolRC RAS publ., 2012: 220 (in Russ.).

52. «My zdes' zhiviom»: social'naja antropologija malogo rossijskogo goroda [“We live here". Social anthropology of a Russian small town] / Ed. by V. A. Tishkov. Moscow, Russian State Humanitarian University publ., 2013: 684 (in Russ.).

53. Nefiodova T. G. Migration Activity of Population and Migrant Workers in Modern Russia. Izvestiya Rossiiskoi Akademii Nauk. Seriya Geograficheskaya, 2015: 3: 41–56 (in Russ.). DOI: https://doi.org/10.15356/0373-2444-2015-3-41-56

54. “Otlichniki” i “neudachniki” rossijskih gorodov [”Excellent students” and “losers” of Russian cities]. Nauchno-obrazovatel'nyj portal IQ, 2013. Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: https://iq.hse.ru/news/177669966.html (in Russ.).

55. Parol' V. I. Socialisticheskij gorod: Urbanizacionnyj process i obraz zhizni gorozhan. Chast' 1 [The socialist city: The urbanization process and the way of life of citizens. Part 1] / Ed. by A. I. Gorjacheva. Tallinn, Valgus, 1982: 174 (in Russ.).

56. Pachenkov O. Urban public space in the face of modern challenges: mobility and “abuse of publicity”. Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2012: 5 (117). Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: https://magazines.gorky.media/nlo/2012/5/publichnoe-prostranstvo-goroda-pered-liczom-vyzovov-sovremennosti-mobilnost-i-zloupotreblenie-publichnostyu.html (in Russ.).

57. Pivovarov Ju. L. Mirovaja urbanizacija i Rossija na poroge XXI veka [Global urbanization and Russia on the threshold of the XXI century]. Obshhestvennye nauki i sovremennost', 1996: 3: 12–22 (in Russ.).

58. “Prigorodnaja revoljucija” v regional’nom srezie: periferijnye territorii na postsovetskom prostranstve [“Suburban revolution” and peripheral urban territories in the post-soviet space: volume of abstracts of the international scientific conference] / Ed. by A. S. Breslavsky. Ulan-Ude, Publishing House of BSC SB RAS publ., 2019: 208 (in Russ.).

59. Prognoznoe social'noe proektirovanie: teoretiko-metodologicheskie i metodicheskie problemy [Predictive social design: theoretical, methodological and methodological problems] / Ed. by T. M. Dridze. Moscow, Nauka, 1994: 304 (in Russ.).

60. Spatial development of small towns: social strategies and practices: [monograph] / Ed. by M. F. Chernysh, V. V. Markin; Foreword: M. K. Gorshkov. Moscow, FCTAS RAS publ., 2020: 523 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.19181/monogr.978-5-89697-335-5.2020

61. Rastvorceva S. N., Manaeva I. V. Single-Industry Towns in the System of Distribution of Productive Forces of Russian Regions. Voprosy territorial'nogo razvitiya, 2016: 5. Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: http://vtr.isert-ran.ru/article/2038 (in Russ.).

62. Kordonsky S., Plusnin Yu., Krasheninnikova Yu., Tukaeva A., Morgunova O., Akhunov D., Boykov D. Russian Province and its Inhabitants (a case of observation and its tentative description). Mir Rossii, 2011: 20(1): 3–33 (in Russ.).

63. Savoskul M. S. Strategii adaptacii etnicheskikh migrantov v lokal'nyh soobshhestvah [Strategies for the adaptation of ethnic migrants in local communities]. Monitoring obshhestvennogo mnenija, 2011: 5: 103–112 (in Russ.).

64. Senjavskij A. S. Rossijskij gorod v 1960-e – 80-e gody [Russian city in the 1960s-80s]. Moscow, IRH RAS publ., 1995: 264 (in Russ.).

65. Sovetskij gorod: social'naja struktura [Soviet city: social structure] / Ed. by N. A. Aitov, V. G. Mordkovich, M. H. Titma. Moscow, Mysl', 1988: 286 (in Russ.).

66. Sogomonov A. Ju. Sovremennyj gorod: strategija identichnosti [The modern city: the strategy of identity.] Neprikosnovennyj zapas, 2010: 2 (70). Accessed 11.02.2021. URL: https://magazines.gorky.media/nz/2010/2/sovremennyj-gorod-strategiya-identichnosti.html (in Russ.).

67. Social'noe prostranstvo bol'shogo goroda [The social space of a city] / G. V. Eremicheva. St. Petersburg, SI FNISC RAS, 2018: 392 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.19181/monograph.2019.4

68. Starovojtova G. V. Jetnicheskaja gruppa v sovremennom sovetskom gorode: sociologicheskie ocherki [Ethnic group in the modern Soviet city: sociological essays]. Leningrad, Nauka, 1987: 176 (in Russ.).

69. Trejvish A. I. Gorod, rajon, strana i mir. Razvitie Rossii glazami stranoveda [City, district, country and the world. The development of Russia through the eyes of a country scientist]. Moscow, Novyj hronograf, 2009: 376 (in Russ.).

70. Treivish A. I., Nefedova T. G. Stolichnost', central'nost', razmery i sopernichestvo gorodov v mire i v Rossii [Stolichnost, centrality, size and rivalry of cities in the world and in Russia]. Geourbanistika i gradostroitel'stvo: teoreticheskie i prikladnye issledovaniya [Geo-urbanism and urban planning: theoretical and applied research]. Ed. by A. G. Makhrova. Moscow, Geogr. f-t MSU publ., 2021: 49–71 (in Russ.)

71. Turgel' I. D., Ushakov V. A. Krupnye promyshlennye goroda Rossii: v poiskah novoj paradigmy razvitija [Large industrial cities of Russia: in search of new development paradigm]. Nacional'nye interesy: prioritety i bezopasnost', 2008: 4: 12: 31–43 (in Russ.).

72. Urbanizacija i razvitie gorodov v SSSR [Urbanization and urban development in the USSR] / Ed. by I. I. Sigov. Leningrad, Nauka, 1985: 256 (in Russ.).

73. Urbanizacija i razvitie regionov oblastnogo urovnja [Urbanization and development of regional level territories] / Ed. by M. N. Mezhevich, I. I. Sigov. Leningrad, Nauka, 1990: 214 (in Russ.).

74. Florinskaja Ju. F. Labor migration from minor Russian towns as a way to survival. Sociological Studies. Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya, 2006: 6: 79–89 (in Russ.).

75. Hohlova A., Tykanova E. Trajectories of Local Communities Self-Organisation in City Space Contests. Sotsiologiya vlasti, 2014: 2: 104–122 (in Russ.).

76. Hohrin E. V., Smol'kov S. A. Mechanisms of formation of city identity of the urbanized territories. Balandin Readings. Novosibirsk, Kryachkov Novosibirsk State University of Architecture, Design and Arts, 2019: XIV: 171–175 (in Russ.).

77. Chirikova A. Je. Nevidimaja vlast' v proekcii malyh rossijskih gorodov [Invisible power in the projection of small Russian cities]. Power and elites, 2015: 2: 326-345 (in Russ.). DOI: 10.31119/pe.2019.6.1

78. Shomina E. S. Stanovlenie zhilishhnogo dvizhenija v Rossii [The Formation of the Housing Movement in Russia]. Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya, 1995: 10: 78−87 (in Russ.).

79. Yanitsky O. N. Social'nye dvizhenija. 100 interv'ju s liderami [Social movements. 100 interviews with leaders]. Moscow, Moskowsky rabochij, 1991: 272 (in Russ.).

80. Yanitsky O. N. Sotsiologiia goroda [Urban studies]. Sotsiologiia v Rossii. [Sociology in Russia] / Ed. by V. A. Yadov. Moscow, Izdatel’stvo Instituta sotsiologii, 1998: 148−169 (in Russ.).