Values and their influence on the perception of patriotism among young people

This article is based on the results of a sociological study of Saratov’s youth, conducted by means of mass survey. Examined are the theoretical approaches towards analyzing patriotism as a social phenomenon based on the notion of its multi-variance. The substantive content of the term “patriotism” is defined to a significant degree by those values which young people appreciate. It is shown that the diversity of value dominants creates seven models of patriotic attitudes: abstract patriotism, traditional, local (including household), liberal, democratic, critical and globalist anti-patriotism. Temporally all of these models shift in different and often times opposite directions. The older one gets – the more “abstract” and “traditional” models of patriotism diminish in terms of their importance, while local and liberal models grow, on the contrary (however, the proportion of household patriotism, which is included into the local category, does decrease). The process of maturing for young people is typically accompanied by a decreasing significance of the anti-patriotic interpretation.

Young people’s patriotism usually manifests itself in everyday life, and less commonly in political and celebratory activities. The younger generation takes the utmost pride in our World War 2 victory, as well as the culture and history of their country. The fact that upbringing has the greatest effect on developing patriotism among young people is confirmed. Other influential factors include (in order of diminishing importance) public organizations, structures of government power, mass media, the education system, religion. The authors’ analysis of the influence of patriotic events revealed that the greatest contributing factor to developing patriotism is when young people meet with veterans of various wars. Second place in that rating of effectiveness goes to watching feature films and reading books. All of Russian society’s social institutions appear to have vast unrealized potential when it comes to cultivating patriotic sentiments and views among young people. In order to fully realize this potential, the authors suggest not only drastically changing our perspective on such an issue as patriotism, but also initiating active work in regions and in local communities, assisting patriotic associations, clubs and other organizations focused on patriotism, paying close attention to the activities of educational institutions, intensifying patriotic work with students on behalf of the armed forces, and, finally, prompting mass media to radically change their perspective on patriotism and patriotic upbringing.

patriotism, homeland, values, youth, social institutions

Afanasiev I.A., Tikhonova S.V. Contours of the Russian Patriotic ideology: to the problem of construction. Vlast` = Power, 2007: 1: 65–70 (In Russ.). 

Aslanov Y.A. Theoretical problems of studying the patriotism of Russian students. Social`no-gumanitarnoe znanie = Social and Humanitarian Knowledge, 2015: 9: 174–181 (In Russ.). DOI: 10.1111/0162-895X.00140 

Dosov Y.N., Konchugov A.V. Questions of patriotism: pluralism and falsifications. Armiya I obschestvo = Army and society, 2009: 4: 81–87 (In Russ.). 

Durkheim E. Value and “real “ judgments. Sotsiologicheskie Issledovanija = Sociological Studies, 1991: 2: 106–114 (In Russ.). 

Erez L, Laborde C. Cosmopolitan Patriotism as a Civic Ideal. American Journal of Political Science, 2020: 1 (64): 191–203. 

Gomberg P. Patriotism Is Like Racism. In: Patriotism. Ed. by I. Primoratz. Amherst, Humanity Books, 2002: 298: 105–112. 

Habermas Y. Historical consciousness and post-traditional identity, Western orientation of Germany. In: Habermas Y. Political works. 2020. 

Ivchenkov S.G.; Sayganova E.V. Patriotism as a component of public consciousness: a generational measurement perspective. Vestnik instituta sotziologii = Institute of Sociology Bulletin, 2019: 10: 1: 104–119 (In Russ.). DOI: https://doi.org/10.19181/vis.2019.28.1.558 

Khaliy I.A. Sociology of patriotism in historical retrospect and its application to the analysis of Russian reality. In: Sociology and society: social inequality and social justice. Ed. by V. A. Mansurov. Moscow, RSA publ., 2016: 2200–2203 (In Russ.). 

Khaliy I.A. Patriotism in the Russian: typology. Sotsiologicheskie Issledovanija = Sociological Studies, 2017: 2: 67–74 (In Russ.). 

Kochieva L.G. Patriotism, nationalism, extremism: a comparative analysis. Molodoy Uchioniy = The Young Scientist, 2014: 20: 483–485 (In Russ.). 

Kogan E.A., Pronina E.I., Karelova D.G. Studying the opinions of high school students about the school and its impact on the development of their personality. Perspektivy nauki I obrazovaniya = Prospects of Science and Education, 2019: (39): 266–273 (In Russ.). 

Kuznetsova N.V., Pronina E.I. Modern concept of identity and new trends in the formation of citizenship and patriotism of high school students. In: Sociology and society: social inequality and social justice. Ed. by V. A. Mansurov. Moscow, RSA publ., 2016: 2250–2260 (In Russ.). 

MacIntyre A. Is Patriotism a Virtue? In: Patriotism. Ed. by I. Primoratz. Amherst, Humanity Books, 2002: 298: 43–58. 

Mazur M.A., Vanykova Y.A. Evolution of concepts of patriotism and Patriotic education. Psykhopedagogika v pravoohranitel’nykh organakh = Psychopedagogics in Law Enforcement Agencies, 2010: 4 (43): 51–53 (In Russ.). 

Müller J.W. Constitutional patriotism. Princeton and Oxford, Princeton University Press, 2007: 177. 

Müller J.W. What is populism? Мoscow, NRU HSE publ., 2018: 135 (In Russ.). 

Nathanson S. In Defense of “Moderate Patriotism”. Ethics April 1989, 2020: 99 (3): 535–552. 

Nussbaum M. Patriotism and cosmopolitanism. LOGOS, 2006: 2 (53): 110–119 (In Russ.). 

Orekhovskaya N. A., Orekhovsky A.V. 2016. Patriotism as a creative ideology of Russian society. Kazanskii pedagogicheskiy zhurnal = Kazan pedagogical magazine, 2016: 3: 204–208 (In Russ.). 

Parsons T. The system of modern societies. Moscow, Aspect Press, 1998: 270 (In Russ.). 

Podyachev K.V. The role of civil society in the translation of values of patriotism: the experience of Russian localities In: Sociology and society: social inequality and social justice. Ed. by V. A. Mansurov. Moscow, RSA publ., 2016: 2312–2322 (In Russ.). 

Popov A.V., Shevchenko O.M., Bineeva N.K., Pechkurov I.V. Sociocultural features of patriotism and formation of state-civil identity in modern Russia. Gosudarstvennoye i munitsipal’noye upravleniye = State and municipal administration. Proceedings of the NKAG, 2017: 4: 221–226 (In Russ.). 

Pronina E.I. Formation of citizenship, patriotism and historical memory in the public consciousness of today’s high school students. In: Theory and practice of social development in the light of modern scientific knowledge. Мoscow, Pero, 2019: 467–469 (In Russ.). 

Schatz R.T., Staub E., Lavine H. On the Varieties of National Attachment: Blind versus Constructive Patriotism. Political Psychology, 1999: 20: 1: 151–174. 

Shaar J. H. The Case for Covenanted Patriotism In: Patriotism. Ed. by I. Primoratz. Amherst: Humanity Books, 2002: 298: 233–257. 

Shevchenko O. M., Vagina V. O. Civil patriotism as an idea of youth consolidation in the South of Russia: specifics and difficulties of formation. Gumanitariy Yuga Rossii = Humanities of the South of Russia, 2017: 6: 3: 300–309 (In Russ.). 

Sullivan J., Frade A., Dietz M. Patriotism, politics, and the presidential election of 1988. American Journal of Political Science, 1992: 36: 200–234. 

Taylor Ch. Why Democracy needs Patriotism. In: Nussbaum M.C. and oth. For love of country? Mass., Beacon Press, 2002: 153: 119–131. 

Trofimov Y.N. About Patriotic ideology in conditions of ideological diversity. Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta. Philosophiya. Sotsiologiya. Politologiya = Bulletin of Tomsk state University. Philosophy. Sociology. Political science, 2016: 3 (35): 23–31 (In Russ.). 

Uzunov V.V. Features of formation of patriotism in the youth environment and its influence on civil identity: experience of the Republic of Crimea. Social`no-gumanitarnoe znanie = Social and Humanitarian Knowledge, 2018; 7: 135–141 (In Russ.). 

Uzunov V.V., Ivanova R.A. Precedent of Crimean patriotism in the context of geopolitical transformation of the region. Gumanitarnye, sotsial’no-economicheskiye i obschestvennye nauki = Humanities, Socio-economic and Social Sciences, 2018: 10: 85–91 (In Russ.). 

Viroli M. For Love of Country. An essay on patriotism and nationalism. Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1995: 206. 

Volkov Y.G., Bineeva N.K. Sociological measurement of citizenship and patriotism in Russian studies. In: Formation of civil patriotism in the South of Russia. Ed. by Y.G. Volkov. Rostov-on-don, Foundation for science and education, 2017: 10–17 (In Russ.). 

Wallerstein I. World system analysis: Management. Moscow, Territoriya buduschego, 2006 (In Russ.). 

Weber M. Selected works. Moscow, Progress, 1990: 808 (In Russ.).